Michigan Contact Lens | Stye vs. Chalazion: Effective Remedies and Prevention Tips

Stye vs. Chalazion: Effective Remedies and Prevention Tips

Eye conditions such as styes and chalazia are prevalent worldwide, affecting millions of people each year. Studies show that approximately 5% of the general population experiences a stye at some point in their lives, while chalazia are more common among individuals with chronic eyelid inflammation, affecting around 25% of those with blepharitis. Though these two conditions may appear similar, they have distinct causes, symptoms, and treatments.

A stye, or hordeolum, is a bacterial infection of the eyelid glands, leading to a red, painful swelling near the eyelashes. In contrast, a chalazion is a non-infectious, painless lump caused by a blocked oil gland within the eyelid. 

Chalazion

A chalazion is a slow-growing, painless lump that forms on the eyelid due to a blocked oil gland. It may initially cause mild irritation but often resolves without treatment.

Causes of Chalazion

  • Blockage of the meibomian glands in the eyelid
  • Chronic inflammation, such as blepharitis (affecting 47% of adults with recurrent chalazion)
  • Skin conditions like rosacea or seborrheic dermatitis
  • High lipid content in tears, which may increase gland blockage risk
  • Poor eyelid hygiene or excessive touching of the eyes

Symptoms of Chalazion

  • Painless, round, or pea-sized lump on the eyelid
  • Mild tenderness or swelling in the early stages
  • Possible blurry vision if the lump presses against the eyeball
  • Increased tearing or dry eye sensation
  • Redness or mild discomfort

Chalazion Treatments

  • Warm compresses (4-5 times a day for 10-15 minutes) help to soften and drain the blocked gland
  • Gentle massage of the eyelid to promote drainage
  • Topical antibiotics or steroid injections in persistent cases
  • Surgical removal in cases where the chalazion doesn’t resolve naturally
  • Avoid squeezing or popping to prevent infection

How to Prevent Chalazion

  • Maintain proper eyelid hygiene by cleaning with warm water and baby shampoo
  • Avoid excessive eye rubbing and touching
  • Use a warm compress regularly if you are prone to chalazia
  • Treat underlying conditions like blepharitis or rosacea
  • Remove makeup thoroughly before sleeping

Hordeolum (Stye)

A hordeolum, commonly known as a stye, is a painful, red lump that forms on the edge of the eyelid due to a bacterial infection in an oil gland or eyelash follicle.

Causes of Hordeolum

  • Bacterial infection (most commonly Staphylococcus aureus, responsible for 90-95% of cases)
  • Blocked sebaceous (oil) glands
  • Poor hygiene, such as touching eyes with unclean hands
  • Use of contaminated or expired eye makeup
  • Chronic eyelid conditions like blepharitis
  • Compromised immune system

Symptoms of Hordeolum

  • Painful, swollen, red bump on the eyelid
  • Tenderness and discomfort
  • Sensitivity to light
  • Crusting or discharge from the lump
  • Watery eyes and irritation

Treatments of Hordeolum

  • Warm compresses (5-10 minutes, 3-4 times a day) to help drainage
  • Antibiotic ointments or eye drops in case of severe infection
  • Pain relievers like ibuprofen to reduce swelling
  • Incision and drainage if the stye persists
  • Avoid touching, squeezing, or popping the stye

How to Prevent Hordeolum?

  • Wash hands before touching your eyes
  • Keep eyelids clean and free from debris
  • Replace old or expired makeup
  • Avoid sharing eye cosmetics or towels
  • Treat underlying eyelid conditions
  • Strengthen immunity through a healthy diet and lifestyle

Difference Between a Stye and a Chalazion

Though similar in appearance, styes and chalazia have distinct differences:

a) Cause:

A stye is caused by a bacterial infection in an eyelash follicle or oil gland, leading to inflammation. A chalazion, on the other hand, results from a blocked oil gland (meibomian gland) without bacterial infection. While styes are infectious, chalazia are non-infectious.

b) Pain Level:

Styes are usually painful, tender, and cause discomfort, especially when blinking. Chalazia, however, are typically painless, although they can become slightly tender if inflamed. Pain is a key differentiator between the two conditions.

c) Location:

A stye commonly develops along the edge of the eyelid or inside it, near an eyelash follicle. A chalazion forms deeper within the eyelid, often on the upper lid, as a lump under the skin. The location helps distinguish them from each other.

d) Appearance:

Styes appear as red, swollen, pus-filled bumps resembling a pimple, sometimes with a white or yellow center. Chalazia look like firm, painless lumps under the eyelid skin, usually larger and less inflamed than styes. The difference in appearance is a notable identifier.

e) Duration:

A stye typically lasts for a few days to a week and often bursts and drains on its own. A chalazion may persist for several weeks to months and can take longer to resolve, sometimes requiring medical intervention if it doesn’t go away.

A Table Comparison Between Stye and Chalazion

FeatureStye (Hordeolum)Chalazion
CauseBacterial infection (Staphylococcus aureus)Blocked meibomian gland
PainPainful, tenderUsually painless
LocationEyelash follicle or edge of eyelidInside eyelid, away from edge
AppearanceRed, swollen, pimple-like bumpRound, firm, non-red lump
TreatmentWarm compresses, antibiotics if infectedWarm compresses, steroid injections, surgery if needed
Duration1-2 weeksWeeks to months
Risk FactorsPoor hygiene, makeup, touching eyesChronic eyelid inflammation (blepharitis, rosacea)

FAQs

1. Can a chalazion turn into a stye?

No, a chalazion does not turn into a stye. A stye is caused by an infection, while a chalazion results from a blocked oil gland. However, a stye can sometimes lead to a chalazion if the infection resolves but leaves behind a blockage.

2. How long does a stye last?

Most styes last between 7-10 days with proper care. Applying warm compresses can speed up healing.

3. When should I see a doctor for a chalazion or stye?

If a chalazion or stye does not improve within a few weeks, is extremely painful, grows rapidly, or affects vision, consult an eye specialist.

4. Can stress cause styes or chalazia?

Stress alone does not cause these conditions, but it can weaken the immune system, making the eyes more susceptible to infections and gland blockages.

5. Is a chalazion contagious?

No, chalazion is not contagious as it is not caused by bacteria. However, a stye, being an infection, can spread if proper hygiene is not maintained.

Shopping Cart0

Cart